You are here:

Too Smart to Fall for a Discount?

Too Smart to Fall for a Discount?

‘Black Friday works on everyone, except me.’

Your friend sends you a Black Friday deal. Headphones, reduced from €199 to €119. A countdown is ticking, only three remain, and twelve other people are apparently looking at them. You recognise the tactics immediately. Anchoring, urgency, scarcity. Surely your friend can see what is happening, right?

Later that evening, you buy a discounted jacket. Obviously, this is different. Winter is coming, the reviews are excellent, and you have wanted one for ages. Besides, you study econometrics. You understand these things.

Your friend fell for the marketing. You identified an opportunity.

At least, that is how you explain it. But perhaps your friend’s headphones are broken. Perhaps they have been comparing prices for weeks. You have supplied plenty of context for your own purchase while judging theirs mainly by the promotional banner.

Before deciding who made the smarter purchase, it might be worth applying the same standard to both.

Two purchases, two standards

Your own reasons are readily available. You remember getting soaked cycling home, know your old jacket’s zip is broken, and have checked whether the replacement is waterproof. Buying it feels like the conclusion of a reasonable process.

The difficulty is that these reasons can be genuine while the advertisement still influences your decision. Needing a jacket does not establish why you chose this particular one, accepted this particular price, or decided that tonight was the moment to buy it.

You would probably recognise that distinction in your friend’s explanation. Their broken headphones would not stop you asking whether the countdown rushed their decision. Yet knowing your own reasons can make equivalent questions feel unnecessary.

Psychologists call the tendency to perceive less bias in ourselves than in others the bias blind spot. Recognising how people can be influenced is easier than determining whether the same influence affected a judgement that feels reasonable to us.

That is why knowing the words “anchoring” and “scarcity” does not settle what happened at checkout.

Knowing the explanation, defending the exception

An experiment by Emily Pronin, Daniel Y. Lin and Lee Ross captures this distinction. Ninety-one Stanford students rated themselves relative to their peers on six characteristics, including dependability, objectivity and selfishness. Overall, 79 gave themselves a favourable comparative rating.

They then read about the better-than-average effect and considered what objective assessments would say about their answers. Among those 79 students, only 24% expected less favourable assessments. Meanwhile, 63% expected their ratings to be confirmed, and 13% thought they had even been too modest. The explanation had apparently reached an exceptionally deserving audience.

Some students could genuinely have possessed favourable qualities. Without independent personality assessments or an unwarned comparison group, the experiment cannot establish that every confident answer was mistaken or that the explanation had no effect.

It does, however, show that understanding a general tendency can coexist comfortably with defending your own case. “Yes, people do that” does not necessarily become “Perhaps I just did that.”

For the jacket buyer, the equivalent response is easy to imagine: of course retailers use discounts to influence customers. But this jacket really is worth buying.

Perhaps it is. The question remains how you reached that conclusion.

Would the jacket survive without the sale?

The authors connect the blind spot to naïve realism: experiencing our own perspective as an objective reading of reality. We can examine the reasons that come to mind without necessarily noticing every influence that helped produce them.

A useful way to question the purchase is therefore to change its presentation in your imagination. Remove the crossed-out €199, the countdown and the stock warning. Leave the same jacket, the same features and the same €119 price.

Would you still want it as much?

This is a counterfactual question. You cannot directly observe both versions of your own decision, so answering confidently does not prove that the promotion was irrelevant. But it helps separate the product’s value to you from the attractiveness of the advertised deal.

Suppose you had previously decided that a suitable jacket was worth €100. A €119 offer remains €19 above that amount, however impressive the reduction from €199 looks. You can reconsider your willingness to pay, but the retailer’s reference price should not do that reconsidering for you.

Give your own basket a second opinion

Before browsing, write down what you need, which features matter and what you would pay. These criteria give you something established before an attractive offer starts supplying reasons to buy.

Then borrow the questions you were ready to ask your friend. Is the replacement necessary? Have you compared the final price elsewhere? Would waiting be a problem, or does it merely feel uncomfortable while the timer runs?

These checks are practical suggestions, not shopping remedies tested in the experiment. Their purpose is to make your reasoning easier to examine.

You do not have to reject a bargain to demonstrate that you understand behavioural economics. A sale can make a useful product affordable. But understanding the sales tactic should prompt you to inspect your decision, rather than reassure you that inspection is unnecessary.

You might still buy the jacket. Just give it the same interrogation you gave the headphones.

 

Reference: Pronin, E., Lin, D. Y., & Ross, L. (2002). The bias blind spot: Perceptions of bias in self versus others. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28(3), 369–381. Read the paper. The shopping examples are illustrative; the research did not investigate Black Friday purchases.